Big 12 officiating is in the hot seat after another weekend rife with inconsistent calls and controversial public statements, focusing critics’ attention on transparency and fairness. BYU’s recent matchup with Arizona State saw the replay command center incorrectly award the Cougars a touchdown after a Bear Bachmeier fumble near the goal line. Experts like Mike Pereira and Terry McCaulay—recognizable rules analysts in the football world—have highlighted this mistake as a case of officials seemingly inventing rules on the fly. Even Arizona State’s Kenny Dillingham publicly noted the questionable decision, intensifying scrutiny on how the conference manages its officiating errors. One concept discussed was the Big 12’s selective approach to acknowledging officiating mistakes. The conversation focused on how the conference has released official statements for certain errors while staying silent on others, leaving fans and teams alike to wonder about the reasoning behind these choices. A key theme that emerged was the impact this inconsistency has on the perception of fairness and integrity across college football. The discussion explored another egregious incident during the same BYU-Arizona State contest: a roughing the snapper penalty charged to BYU’s Faletau Satuala after a blocked field goal. Once again, both Pereira and McCaulay labeled the call as incorrect, yet the Big 12 issued no formal acknowledgment. Several points were raised, including the potential damage to fan trust and the risk of fueling conspiracy theories in an age of widespread skepticism. Questions were posed about Brett Yormark’s leadership as he prepares to exit his role—is the inconsistent officiating response a sign of deeper issues in the conference’s approach? As fans and programs demand accountability, the spotlight is now firmly on whether the Big 12 will address every officiating gaffe transparently or continue a pattern of selective admissions, with massive implications for the league’s credibility and the spirit of competition.
Big 12 officiating is in the hot seat after another weekend rife with inconsistent calls and controversial public statements, focusing critics’ attention on transparency and fairness. BYU’s recent matchup with Arizona State saw the replay command center incorrectly award the Cougars a touchdown after a Bear Bachmeier fumble near the goal line. Experts like Mike Pereira and Terry McCaulay—recognizable rules analysts in the football world—have highlighted this mistake as a case of officials seemingly inventing rules on the fly. Even Arizona State’s Kenny Dillingham publicly noted the questionable decision, intensifying scrutiny on how the conference manages its officiating errors.
One concept discussed was the Big 12’s selective approach to acknowledging officiating mistakes. The conversation focused on how the conference has released official statements for certain errors while staying silent on others, leaving fans and teams alike to wonder about the reasoning behind these choices. A key theme that emerged was the impact this inconsistency has on the perception of fairness and integrity across college football. The discussion explored another egregious incident during the same BYU-Arizona State contest: a roughing the snapper penalty charged to BYU’s Faletau Satuala after a blocked field goal. Once again, both Pereira and McCaulay labeled the call as incorrect, yet the Big 12 issued no formal acknowledgment.
Several points were raised, including the potential damage to fan trust and the risk of fueling conspiracy theories in an age of widespread skepticism. Questions were posed about Brett Yormark’s leadership as he prepares to exit his role—is the inconsistent officiating response a sign of deeper issues in the conference’s approach? As fans and programs demand accountability, the spotlight is now firmly on whether the Big 12 will address every officiating gaffe transparently or continue a pattern of selective admissions, with massive implications for the league’s credibility and the spirit of competition.
Support Locked On Cougars Hits:
Follow & Subscribe on all Podcast platforms and on YouTube!
Join the NEW Locked On Cougars Everydayer Club by clicking here!
If you never miss an episode, it’s time to make it official. Join the Locked On Everydayer Club and get ad-free audio, access to our members-only Discord, and more — all built for our most loyal fans.
Click here to learn more and join your team’s community: https://lockedonpodcasts.com/everydayerclub
Jake Hatch brings you daily coverage of the BYU Cougars with the Locked On Cougars Podcast. Locked On Cougars brings BYU fans the latest news and comprehensive coverage when it comes to the BYU football and basketball programs as well as a look at the other teams in the BYU athletic department. Jake gives you his unique insights and insider information about the Cougs as they continue "on the trail to fame and glory" every weekday, along with interviews with players, coaches, experts, and alumni that you will not find anywhere else.
Support Us By Supporting Our Sponsors!
KALSHI: Today's hit is sponsored by Kalshi. Download Kalshi and use code HIT to get $25 when you trade $25.18+ only. Restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Event contract trading involves risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Kalshi products are not available in all jurisdictions. Prices, values, and available markets may differ from those mentioned. For more information see kalshi.com/regulatory
5-Hour Energy: Today's hit is sponsored by 5-Hour Energy. Bring the APPLE ORCHARD experience where ever you go this fall with a CARAMEL APPLE 5-HOUR ENERGY SHOT, available online now at https://5hourENERGY.com or on Amazon
Follow the Locked On Cougars podcast on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter to stay up-to-date with the latest with regards to the podcast and BYU sports news. Please remember to subscribe, enable notifications, rate and review the show.
If you are interested in advertising with Locked On Cougars or the Locked On Podcast Network, please email us at LockedOnBYU@gmail.com.